aFe Momentum GT vs Magnum FORCE Stage-2: Which Cold Air Intake, and Pro 5R or Pro DRY S?
A stock 2019 Silverado 1500 5.3L made 263.4 hp at the wheels on aFe's own Dynojet. Bolt on a Momentum GT with a Pro 5R filter and the same truck made 273.3. Swap to a Magnum FORCE Stage-2 with the same filter and it made 270.3. Change either one to the dry Pro DRY S filter and peak power drops by about 1 hp.
So the aFe Momentum GT vs Magnum FORCE choice is not really about horsepower. It is about heat, noise, dust and how you feel about oiling a filter. This guide settles both halves of the decision: which housing, and which filter media, for trucks, Jeeps, Mustangs and BMWs.
Our numbers come from aFe's product pages and dyno sheets, our storefront prices, and owner threads on GM-Trucks, 5thGenRams, JLWranglerForums, Bob Is The Oil Guy and Bimmerpost.
The Short Answer
On aFe's 2019 Silverado 5.3L tests, all four combinations finished within 4 hp at peak. Buy the Momentum GT for a sealed box with a sight window and a calmer sound. Buy the Magnum FORCE Stage-2 for the open filter, more aggressive sound and a price $29 to $62 lower with us. Pick Pro DRY S unless you want maximum flow and will re-oil.
Momentum GT vs Magnum FORCE: What Actually Differs
The Momentum GT is a closed, one-piece plastic airbox that wraps around the filter, while the Magnum FORCE Stage-2 is an open-top box that leaves the filter exposed under the hood. Both are made from XLPE (cross-linked polyethylene, a heat-resistant plastic), both bolt to factory mounting points, and both feed from the factory air inlet scoop on the 2019 Silverado kits, according to aFe.

On the 2018 to 2023 Mustang GT version, aFe adds an auxiliary inlet that pulls extra air from the inner fender. On the Silverado, aFe says the filter comes out by removing only the intake tube.

The Magnum FORCE Stage-2 trades the lid for flow and sound. aFe's own bullet calls it an open-element design that "delivers an aggressive air intake sound." On the Mustang GT kit, aFe says the open box seals against the underside of the hood once it is closed, which is how it keeps engine bay heat out.
That hood seal is the honest limit of the design: it only works with the hood closed and the foam in good shape. aFe publishes no intake air temperature data for either system, so any claim that one runs cooler in traffic is design logic, not a measurement.
Same Truck, Same Dyno: aFe's Silverado Numbers
The fairest Momentum GT vs Magnum FORCE comparison we found is aFe's own 2019 Silverado 1500 5.3L test, because all four kits were measured against one shared baseline run. The truck was on a Dynojet 424xLC chassis dyno in 3rd gear with stock exhaust and 33x12.50R18 tires, so these are wheel horsepower figures. aFe's sheets list no fuel and no tune.
| 2019 Silverado 5.3L kit | aFe "up to" gain | Peak on aFe's sheet | Measured flow | Our price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stock airbox | Baseline | 263.4 whp, 275.3 lb-ft | 505 cfm | n/a |
| Momentum GT Pro 5R (50-70066R) | +10 hp, +16 lb-ft | 273.3 whp, 287.7 lb-ft | 650 cfm | $375 |
| Momentum GT Pro DRY S (50-70066D) | +8 hp, +13 lb-ft | 272.0 whp, 286.9 lb-ft | 630 cfm | $388 |
| Magnum FORCE Pro 5R (54-13058R) | +12 hp, +20 lb-ft | 270.3 whp, 287.1 lb-ft | 710 cfm | $345 |
| Magnum FORCE Pro DRY S (54-13058D) | +8 hp, +14 lb-ft | 269.4 whp, 288.0 lb-ft | 685 cfm | Not stocked |
Read the two power columns differently. aFe's "up to" figure is the biggest gap at any single rpm, around 3,200 rpm on this truck. The peak column is the top of the pull.
Flow is measured at 7 inches of water, aFe's standard bench test. The Magnum FORCE outflows the Momentum GT by 60 cfm with the oiled filter and 55 cfm with the dry one, and the stock airbox already flows 505 cfm. On a stock 5.3L, that extra bench flow bought about 2 to 3 hp more in the midrange and about 3 hp less at peak.
aFe's own list prices for these four kits run $483.75 to $543.75. Prices vary by dealer.
Pro 5R vs Pro DRY S: The Filter Decision
Pro 5R is aFe's five-layer oiled cotton gauze media and flows the most; Pro DRY S is a three-layer dry synthetic media that flows slightly less and needs no oil. aFe's own filter guide puts it plainly: pick Pro 5R for maximum airflow, and pick Pro DRY S for oil-free convenience, where it "offers slightly more protection, but sacrifices a slight amount of airflow."
On the Silverado, that sacrifice was 20 to 25 cfm and about 1 hp at peak. With us the dry version usually costs $10 to $14 more; the median gap across 142 matched aFe intake kits is about $13.
The oil question is where people get burned. aFe says its filter oil will not interfere with a mass airflow (MAF) sensor "when properly maintained," and that qualifier matters: the oil-fouled MAF stories owners tell involve oiled filters in general, and re-oiling is the step a busy owner is most likely to rush. A dry filter takes that variable away. aFe recommends cleaning either media every 25,000 to 30,000 miles, sooner in dust.
Dust is where the common advice goes wrong, and it surprised us too. aFe rates Pro DRY S for "street and light off-road use" and calls the idea that dry filters are best for dust a common belief that does not always hold. For sand, desert and trail dust, aFe points to Pro GUARD 7, a seven-layer oiled media it rates at 99.7% efficiency under ISO 5011, its highest. For diesels, aFe built Pro 10R, a ten-layer oiled media with expanded metal support, for its Momentum HD kits.
Rule of thumb. Pavement and you will not re-oil: Pro DRY S. Pavement and you want every cfm: Pro 5R. Dirt roads, desert or trail dust weekly: Pro GUARD 7 where your kit offers it.
Prices and Fitment by Vehicle
Most popular trucks, Jeeps and muscle cars can get both housings, and the Magnum FORCE is usually the cheaper one. Prices are ours; fitment follows our listings.
| Vehicle | Momentum GT Pro 5R | Momentum GT Pro DRY S | Magnum FORCE Pro 5R | Magnum FORCE Pro DRY S |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silverado / Sierra 1500 5.3L, 2019 to 2026 | $375 | $388 | $345 | Not stocked |
| F-150 5.0L, 2021 to 2025 | $375 | $388 | $345 | $356 |
| Wrangler JL / Gladiator JT 3.6L, 2018 to 2025 | $366 | $375 | $336 | $345 (JL, 2018 to 2023) |
| Mustang GT S550 5.0L, 2018 to 2023 | $388 | $403 | Not stocked | Not stocked |
| BMW G20 M340i, G22 M440i, G42 M240i (B58), 2020 on | $412 | $428 | Not stocked | Not stocked |
The JL Wrangler also gets a Momentum GT with Pro GUARD 7 media at $388, which is the one we would put on a Jeep that sees real trail dust. The Magnum FORCE Stage-2 XP version for the JL runs $356 with Pro 5R and $366 with Pro DRY S.
On the Mustang GT, aFe's sheets show a different story from the Silverado. The Momentum GT Pro 5R took an automatic S550 GT from 389.0 to 403.2 whp at peak in 6th gear with the factory exhaust, and aFe's headline is +18 hp at 6,250 rpm; the two runs were 9 days apart at 94 F and 101 F. The Magnum FORCE Pro 5R sheet starts from a separate 405.6 whp baseline run, so the two Mustang headlines cannot be compared directly.
BMW owners should read the B58 sheet before buying for power. On a 2020 G20 M340i with the factory ECU and factory downpipe, the aFe Momentum GT Pro 5R for the B58 G20, G22 and G42 ($412) made 374.6 whp at peak against 374.7 stock. aFe's +13 hp claim is real, but it lives around 4,700 rpm, and the factory tune still sets the peak. Our B58 bolt-on build guide puts the intake late in the order for exactly this reason.
California buyers, check before ordering. aFe states that the Silverado, Mustang GT and B58 kits above are not CARB exempt and cannot be sold for California registered vehicles. Some aFe intakes do carry a CARB Executive Order, such as EO D-550-58 on the Momentum GT Pro DRY S for the 2019 and later RAM 1500 5.7L HEMI, so check aFe's listing for your exact engine.
What Owners Actually Say
Owner threads agree on one thing: both intakes change the sound far more than the stopwatch. Paraphrased, with the forum named:
- 2016 Silverado, Momentum GT (GM-Trucks). Louder than stock but "not obnoxious," and the owner believed it posted the best gain over stock of the intakes he had seen tested.
- 2014 Sierra, earlier aFe Momentum with dry filter (GM-Trucks). Said it would not improve mileage or horsepower and the gains were mostly sound and looks; a plug for the front opening of the box reportedly cuts the noise about in half. He still recommended it for build quality.
- 2018 JL Rubicon, Momentum GT Pro DRY S (JLWranglerForums). Deeper sound than the K&N intakes he ran before, quicker throttle response, no mileage change yet; the filter comes out by removing one bolt and lifting the box.
- Fifth generation RAM 1500, aFe intake plus exhaust (5thGenRams). Loved the wide-open-throttle sound and felt a slight gain, but could not separate it from the exhaust. Another member preferred the Momentum because it connects to the factory cold air duct behind the grille.
- 2019 JL Unlimited, aFe dry filter in the desert (JLWranglerForums). Works well, but takes a long time to dry after washing; he called oiled filters a caked mess in dirt. In the same thread a 2021 Rubicon diesel owner in a dusty area went back to paper, citing aFe's own light off-road rating for dry media.
The one that went back in the box. A 2015 Silverado 6.2L crew cab owner on GM-Trucks installed a Momentum GT with the dry filter. It was quiet at part throttle but boomed under medium and heavy throttle, peaking near 3,500 rpm. He spent about 20 hours on plugs, sound deadening foam and fender liner work with no change, then refit the factory airbox after 3 weeks and 500 miles and sold the aFe. A second member pulled the same intake after a week for the same noise.
On oiled filters and MAF sensors, the evidence is mixed and none of it is aFe specific. On Bob Is The Oil Guy, an owner who converted an 1987 Mustang GT to a MAF found an oiled K&N kept fouling the sensor until he went back to a stock airbox with a panel filter. In the same thread, several owners reported 60,000 to 80,000 miles on oiled filters with no MAF trouble. On Bimmerpost, a turbo BMW owner running a dry Pro DRY S found oil on his MAF anyway; members traced that kind of contamination to the crankcase vent, and a later owner's dealer found a leaking vent hose. An oily MAF is not always the filter's fault.
Mistakes We See
- Buying for horsepower on a stock turbo engine. On the B58, aFe's own sheet shows peak power unchanged. Buy the intake for sound, filter access and response, and budget for a tune if power is the goal.
- Comparing headline numbers across different dyno sheets. The Mustang GT kits were tested on different baselines. Only the Silverado set shares one baseline run.
- Treating more oil as more filtering. Re-oil a Pro 5R exactly as aFe's instructions say, and wipe the intake tube when you service it. If you won't follow the re-oil steps, buy Pro DRY S.
- Choosing Pro DRY S for desert use. aFe rates it for light off-road only. Weekly trail dust calls for Pro GUARD 7 where offered.
- Ordering the wrong year split. The Wrangler JL Magnum FORCE Pro DRY S is listed for 2018 to 2023, while the Pro 5R version runs to 2025. Check the listing's years and engine before you order.
- Expecting stock quiet from a sealed box. The Momentum GT is the quieter of the two, and one Silverado owner still sent his back for the boom.
Who This Is For (and Who Should Skip It)
The Momentum GT suits owners who want a covered look, a filter check through the window, and a sound that stays polite until the pedal goes down. The Magnum FORCE suits owners who want the filter on display, the more aggressive induction sound aFe advertises, and the lower price.
Skip both if you tow long grades with a stock tune and want measurable power; the Silverado gains are 6 to 10 whp at peak. Skip both if a cabin boom at 3,500 rpm would bother you or your passengers. And on a stock B58, aFe's own sheet shows no peak gain, so buy it for sound or wait until you tune.
If It Were Our Car
- 2019 and later Silverado or Sierra 1500 5.3L: the Momentum GT Pro DRY S for the 5.3L GM trucks and SUVs ($388). It held the higher peak of the two dry kits on aFe's sheets, and a work truck has no time for re-oiling.
- Same truck, sound first: the Magnum FORCE Stage-2 Pro 5R for the 5.3L ($345). It had the biggest midrange gain on aFe's sheet and costs $29 less than the Momentum GT Pro 5R.
- Wrangler JL 3.6L on trails: Momentum GT with Pro GUARD 7 ($388). The sealed box plus aFe's dust media is the combination built for that use.
- Mustang GT 2018 to 2023: Momentum GT Pro 5R ($388). aFe's sheet shows a 14 whp peak gain with factory exhaust, the largest peak gain on any sheet we reviewed.
- BMW B58 on a stock tune: skip the full intake for now. With a tune, the Momentum GT is the sealed box we would choose.
What It Pairs With
aFe builds step-up versions of both families. Momentum XP uses aluminum intake tubes on kits like the 2015 to 2020 F-150 5.0L, Momentum HD covers diesels such as the L5P Duramax with Pro 10R media, and Magnum FORCE Stage-2 XP versions exist for the JL Wrangler and the 2017 to 2023 Challenger and Charger Hellcat.
Not ready for a full system? aFe's Magnum FLOW drop-in filters fit the factory airbox in the same two media. Shopping a VW or Audi instead? Our APR intake guide for the GTI, Golf R, S4 and RS3 covers the same sealed versus open question on those cars.
We are an authorized dealer for every brand we carry, including aFe POWER, and in stock hardware ships fast. If your vehicle is not in the tables above, send us the year, model and engine and we will match the part number.
The Bottom Line
On aFe's own 2019 Silverado 5.3L tests, the Momentum GT and Magnum FORCE Stage-2 finished within 4 whp of each other at peak, so let sound, looks and price decide. The Magnum FORCE flows more on the bench, sounds louder, and costs about $29 less on most trucks. The Momentum GT made slightly more peak power, hides the filter behind a sight window, and suits owners who want it quieter. For the filter, Pro DRY S costs about $13 more and gave up roughly 1 hp, which is a fair trade if you never want to oil anything. Dusty trail use calls for Pro GUARD 7, and a stock B58 barely needs either intake for power.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the aFe Momentum GT better than the Magnum FORCE Stage-2?
Neither wins on power. On aFe's 2019 Silverado 5.3L tests the Momentum GT Pro 5R peaked at 273.3 whp and the Magnum FORCE Pro 5R at 270.3 whp. Choose the Momentum GT for a sealed, quieter box and the Magnum FORCE for the open look, louder sound and lower price.
Should I get the Pro 5R or Pro DRY S filter?
Pro DRY S for most daily drivers and work trucks: no oil, slightly better protection by aFe's rating, and about 1 hp less at peak on the Silverado. Pro 5R if you want maximum flow and will clean and re-oil it properly.
Which aFe filter is best for off-road dust?
Pro GUARD 7, which aFe rates at 99.7% efficiency under ISO 5011. aFe rates Pro DRY S for street and light off-road use only.
Will an oiled aFe filter damage my MAF sensor?
aFe says its filter oil will not affect the MAF when the filter is properly maintained. The MAF trouble owners report involves oiled filters in general rather than aFe specifically, and some oily MAF sensors trace to crankcase vent leaks instead of the filter.
Will an aFe intake void my warranty?
No. The FTC says your warranty stays in effect with aftermarket parts, and a manufacturer must prove the part caused the damage before it can deny coverage for that repair.
Are aFe intakes legal in California?
Only the ones with a CARB Executive Order. aFe states the Silverado 5.3L, Mustang GT and B58 kits in this guide are not CARB exempt, while some others, such as the RAM 1500 5.7L Momentum GT Pro DRY S under EO D-550-58, are.





